Original Broadway Cast

 Josh Gad - Elder Cunningham

Andrew Rannells - Elder Price

Nikki M. James - Nabulungi

Rory O'Malley - Elder McKinley, Moroni

Michael Potts - Mafala Hatimbi

Lewis Cleale – Mission Training Center Voice, Price’s Dad, Joseph Smith, Mission President

Brian Tyree Henry – General, Ensemble

Michael James Scott – Doctor, Ensemble

Kevin Duda - Cunningham's Dad, Ensemble, Elder Price(Understudy), Mission Training Center Voice(Understudy), Price’s Dad(Understudy), Joseph Smith(Understudy), Mission President (Understudy)

Jason Michael Snow – Mormon, Ensemble

Rema Webb – Mrs. Brown, Ensemble

John Eric Parker – Guard, Ensemble, Mafala Hatimbi(Understudy)

Tommar Wilson – Guard, Ensemble

Benjamin Schrader – Ensemble, Elder Cunningham(Understudy) Mission Training Center Voice(Understudy), Price’s Dad(Understudy), Joseph Smith(Understudy), Mission President(Understudy)

Asmeret Ghebremichael – Ensemble, Nabulungi(Understudy)

Scott Barnhardt – Ensemble, Elder McKinley(Understudy)

Brian Sears – Ensemble, Elder McKinley(Understudy)

Justin Bohon - Ensemble

Darlesia Cearcy - Ensemble

Clark Johnsen - Ensemble

Lawrence Stallings - Ensemble

Maia Nkenge Wilson - Ensemble

Jared Gertner - Elder Cunningham (Standby)

Nick Spangler – Swing, Elder Price(Understudy)

Ta'Rea Campbell – Swing, Nabulungi(Understudy)

Tyson Jennette – Swing, Mafala Hatimbi(Understudy)

Graham Bowen - Swing